 |
| For Whom the Bell Tolls |
For Whom the Bell Tolls takes place over three days in the Spanish Civil War, and Hemingway uses this compression — borrowed, consciously, from the classical unities of time and place — to create an intensity that his more expansive novels only occasionally achieve. The entire novel is a kind of countdown, and everyone inside it knows it.
Robert Jordan is an American volunteer assigned to blow up a bridge behind enemy lines. His task is specific and logistical and he understands exactly what it requires, including the probability that it will require his life. What the novel is interested in is not the mission itself but what Jordan thinks and feels and understands during the three days he spends in the mountains with a band of guerrillas before the detonation. Hemingway's subject is always the same: how does a person conduct himself when the situation is untenable?
Pilar is the novel's most fully realized character — larger, older, and more honest than anyone else in the book, including Jordan. She has seen enough of the war to know what it does to people, and she speaks about this knowledge with a directness that makes the other characters flinch. Her reading of Jordan's palm and her reluctance to tell him what she sees is one of the novel's most effective scenes: understated, frightening, true.
Pablo, the guerrilla leader whom Pilar has largely displaced, is a portrait of moral collapse under sustained pressure. He was once decisive; the war has made him calculating in the most cowardly sense. His arc — and his eventual partial recovery — is one of the novel's more honest acknowledgments that courage is not a fixed quality but something that can be lost and, sometimes, partially recovered.
Maria, the young woman Jordan falls in love with during his three days in the mountains, has been criticized as a projection of male fantasy, and the criticism has merit — she exists primarily in relation to Jordan rather than independently. But Hemingway is at least honest about the function she serves: in a situation defined by violence and death, the need for tenderness becomes extreme, and the relationship is as much about that need as about any realistic romantic possibility.
The novel's final pages are Hemingway at his best — controlled, dignified, the prose stripped to what is absolutely necessary. Jordan's waiting, alone, is the culmination of everything the novel has been building toward: a meditation on what it means to act with purpose when the outcome is already written.
Post a Comment